Deadly Divas True Crime Podcast
We’re Sarah & Tina—2 divas with a serious true crime obsession.
It all started on our first trip away together, when we realized we could spend hours listening to true crime podcasts, watching documentaries, swapping theories, and talking endlessly about the cases that fascinated us.
So naturally, starting our own true crime podcast seemed like the next logical step!
Join us each week as we dive into cases ranging from infamous crimes and shocking scandals to unsolved mysteries, disappearances, and stories you may have never heard before.
Have a case you think we should cover, or just want to say hi? We’d love to hear from you at contact@deadlydivaspodcast.com!
Be divas… not deadly!
Episodes
84 episodes
Christa Pike: Execution Update
Sarah brings us an update following the failed execution of Christa Pike.More drama surrounded this case this week, after a last-minute stay of execution was issued and then promptly overturned, and then the execution itself did not go a...
Episode 43: The Watcher
Tina leads our first Spooktacular episode with the chilling true story of The Watcher.When Derek and Maria Broaddus purchased their dream home at 657 Boulevard in Westfield, New Jersey, they thought they were moving ...
In the Headlines: The Cornell 7
Tina leads this In the Headlines episode on The Cornell 7.A former Cornell student alleges she was drugged and sexually assaulted by multiple Chi Phi fraternity members in 2024. During the alleged assault, a Snapchat mess...
Episode 42: The Yogurt Shop Murders
Tina leads this episode about the case that haunted Austin, Texas for more than three decades — The Yogurt Shop Murders.In December 1991, four teenage girls were found murdered inside a neighborhood yogurt shop after firefighters ...
In the Headlines: Caleb Flynn
Tina leads this In the Headlines episode covering the ongoing murder trial of Caleb Flynn, a former American Idol contestant and church worship leader accused of killing his wife, Ashley Flynn.We break down some of the most shocking test...
In the Headlines: Christa Pike
Sarah leads her first In the Headlines episode as we discuss the disturbing case of Christa Pike — the only woman currently on Tennessee’s death row.In 1995, 18-year-old Pike was convicted of the brutal murder of 19-year-old Colleen Slem...
Episode 41: Pam Hupp
Sarah leads this episode about the unbelievable case of Pam Hupp.In 2011, Betsy Faria was found murdered inside her Missouri home, and suspicion quickly fell on her husband, Russ. Despite having an alibi backed by multiple witnesses, Ru...
In the Headlines: KJ Biermann
Today on In the Headlines, Tina breaks down the disturbing allegations involving KJ Biermann, the son of Real Housewives of Atlanta star Kim Zolciak and former NFL player Kroy Biermann.What initially looked like another h...
In the Headlines: Andrew Tate
Andrew and Tristan Tate are facing an increasingly complicated web of criminal allegations and legal proceedings spanning multiple countries.In this episode of In the Headlines, Tina breaks down how the Tate brothers went from the...
Episode 40: Lizzie Borden
Tina leads this episode about the infamous unsolved double homicide that rocked Fall River, Massachusetts, on August 4, 1892.Andrew and Abby Borden were brutally attacked inside their own home, roughly an hour and a half apart, leaving b...
Episode 39: Christina Morris - Labor Day Bonus Episode
Sarah leads this episode about the disappearance of 23-year-old Christina Morris — a Texas woman whose family, friends, and an army of volunteers refused to give up searching for her.In the early morning hours of August 30, 2014, Christi...
In the Headlines: Lindsay Clancy
Tina leads another episode of In the Headlines.After 6 weeks of testimony and 7 days of deliberations, the Lindsay Clancy trial has ended in a mistrial.In this episode, I'm breaking down what happened, the evidence surrounding Lin...
Episode 38: After Show
Join us for the Heather Elvis After Show!
Episode 38: Heather Elvis
Sarah leads this episode about the mysterious disappearance of 20-year-old Heather Elvis, a beautiful, outgoing young woman from Myrtle Beach, South Carolina.In December 2013, Heather seemingly vanished without a trace. Her abandoned car...
In the Headlines: The Horsch House of Horrors
Tina is back with another In the Headlines episode covering a disturbing and rapidly developing investigation out of Philadelphia.What began with a routine parking violation in June 2026 quickly spiraled into something investigato...
Episode 37: After Show
Join us for The TikTok Dance Cult After Show!
Episode 37: The TikTok Dance Cult
Tina leads this episode into the unsettling world of 7M Films, Shekinah Church, and the man at the center of it all: Robert Shinn.What appeared on social media to be a group of talented young dancers living their dreams in Los Angeles wo...
In The Headlines: Laken Snelling
Welcome to Deadly Divas: In The Headlines!Tina brings you something a little different with a shorter episode covering a case making headlines right now.In August 2025, University of Kentucky student and former STUNT team member ...
Episode 36: After Show
Join us for The Idaho 4 Murders After Show!
Episode 36: The Idaho 4 Murders
Sarah leads this episode about the murders of four University of Idaho students — Kaylee Goncalves, Madison Mogen, Xana Kernodle, and Ethan Chapin — and the man who ultimately admitted to killing them, Bryan Kohberger.In the early mornin...
Episode 35: After Show
Join us for the Lorena Bobbitt After Show!
Episode 35: Lorena Bobbitt
Tina leads this episode about the infamous case of Lorena Bobbitt (now Lorena Gallo.)You may think you know this story, but we're peeling back the layers on the marriage and everything that came before (and after) that fateful night when...